Measurment Artifacts

A free electronic newsletter covering news and other topics for those interested in RF safety issues.

LIVE, Web-Based RF Safety Training

Home
Up
Equipment Accuracy
Calibration
Spatial Averaging
Measurment Artifacts

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What Are Measurement Artifacts?

Measurement artifacts are the technical reasons why the results that you observe may not be accurate.  Some of these artifacts are fairly well known in the industry.  Others are more obscure.  The artifacts described are not related to any single probe, probe type, or manufacturer.  They are not all defects in design since they may or may not contribute to any significant error.  Some artifacts are due to design and are present in only some probes.  In other cases the artifacts may be the result of a conscious decision and trade off made during the design process.  The following are some of the more common measurement artifacts.

Artifact

Indication

Description

Zero drift

Unstable readings, field level indicated when there isn’t any, or a negative indication

The reasons for zero drift are complicated.  Sometimes it can have a significant impact on your readings while at other times it is insignificant.  See Zero Drift.

Out-of-band pick-up

Readings higher than expected.

Probes can be oversensitive to signals above their rated frequency range.  See Out-of-Band Response.

Potential field pick-up at lower frequencies

Readings higher than expected.

Probe and meter can function as a voltmeter.  Meter reading is due to a voltage difference rather than an RF field.  Strong electric fields from power frequency sources, such as transmission lines, can induce high fields into the transmission lines of the probe.  See Potential Field/Power Frequency Immunity.

Multi-signal error

Readings higher than expected.

Diode probes can go out of “square law” and provide “linear” detection.  See RMS Detection.

Static pick-up

Readings higher than expected.

Rapid movement of the probe and/or the presence of a flag or an article of clothing that can hold a charge can result in very high, momentary false readings.

Light sensitivity

Readings lower than expected, or possibly negative.  

If both light effects and a real signal are present, the signal level will be underestimated.  If no significant signal is present, there will be a negative or zero indication.

Peak detection of pulsed fields

Readings higher than expected.

Diodes tend to peak detect pulsed signals.  See Peak Detection of Pulsed Fields.

H-field probe detects E-field

Readings can be either higher or lower, depending on the mechanism.  

Significant only when almost all of the energy is in the E-field. 

Zero Drift

Most instruments today have digital readouts.  Zero drift is easier to understand when you think of an analog meter movement.  When no signal is present, the needle should be on zero.  When it is off a little, you correct the problem by adjusting a small screw or knob on the meter.  You perform a similar task when you use a scale to weigh yourself.  For some instruments, you must insure that the instrument is not measuring anything while you “zero” it in the same way that you set the meter on the scale to zero before you get on it.

Digital meters have the same requirements but it is a bit more difficult to visualize and to detect zero drift.  And most digital meters do not automatically display negative numbers.  You can see when the needle goes below zero on an analog meter.  A digital meter may show a negative sign, a negative sign with a value, or simply 0.0 units. 

Zero drift is largely caused by temperature changes.  This is due to both the changes in temperature that occur as the instrument “warms up” and from changes in the ambient temperature over time. 

Equipment design impacts the amount of drift.  Probes with high gain amplifiers magnify the amount of drift.   Some equipment is designed with the diodes close to saturation so that there will be little drift.  But this design approach gives up RMS detection, which can lead to far bigger measurement errors than zero drift. 

To minimize zero drift...

bullet

Let the equipment acclimate to the ambient temperature for at least 30 minutes.  Do not take an instrument out of a heated car and try to immediately make measurements in the cold or vice versa.

bullet

Turn the equipment on, set it up, and then zero it.  Wait 2-5 minutes and zero it again.  This allows the equipment to warm up and stabilize.

To check for zero drift...

bullet

Shield the probe occasionally and make sure that you get a zero reading.  A positive value indicates positive zero drift. 

bullet

Check for a negative indication or “all zeroes.  Most sites have some energy present.  If the meter is always indicating 0.0, then the system may have drifted in the negative direction.

Potential Field/Power Frequency Immunity

Survey instruments can be oversensitive to signals below their rated frequency range for a variety of reasons.   The most common problem occurs because a meter and probe, especially when separated by a cable, can be at different voltage potentials when in close proximity to a radiator.  The problem is acute near AM radio antennas (560 kHz to 1600 kHz), near industrial process equipment that operates at 50 kHz to 400 kHz and near power frequency sources, such as power transmission lines.  This artifact occurs because the impedance of the sensor antenna becomes as high as or even higher than the impedance of the transmission line.  The result can be some abnormally high meter readings. 

There is a simple way to tell if the indicated value represents a true RF field or a voltage pick-up.  Simply shield the probe to with a metal can, aluminum foil, or some of the fabric used in RF protective garments.  If the meter indication drops significantly, then you were reading a true RF field.  But if the shielding has little impact on the indicated value, then you are looking at an indication of a voltage field.  The shielding will block RF from the sensor but will have little impact on the survey instrument’s tendency to act as a voltmeter.  Note that it is important that you do not touch this shield or let it touch a conductive object. 

To minimize or eliminate the problem...   

bullet

If the meter and probe are isolated electrically, then the problem cannot occur.  The only way to do that is to connect the probe to the meter with a fiber optic cable.

bullet

If the meter and probe are at the same or almost the same electric potential, then the problem is minimized.  If possible, eliminate the cable and connect the probe directly to the meter.  While this is often an awkward way to work, this is the one place where it is the right thing to do.  If you cannot do that, coil the connecting cable up and move the handle of the probe along side the meter.

Another related problem occurs at these low frequencies if you are holding the meter.  Your body can act as an antenna or a ground when you hold the survey instrument.  The best approach is to set the instrument down on a non-conductive stand of some type—even a cardboard box will work.  Stand back and read the meter.  Alternately, attach an insulated handle to the meter.  Hold the meter away from your body by holding the insulated handle.

Peak Detection of Pulsed Fields

Probes that have diode sensors are generally not suitable for measuring radar pulses.  They can be used but only when the field levels are very low.  And since it is difficult to know the transition point for a particular instrument, it is safer to always use a thermocouple probe to measure radar pulses.  The diodes tend to peak detect and you can get readings that are 10 to 100 times higher than the actual RMS field level. 

Diodes have a square law detection characteristic at low levels and linear characteristic at high levels.  This is because the video resistance of the diode changes with the level of RF current through the diode.  The resistance decreases with the amplitude of the pulse which increases the efficiency or sensitivity of the diode as a rectifier.  The low resistance allows rapid charging of the circuit capacitance.  The diode becomes a peak detector rather than providing an integrated averaged dc output.

 

Home ] Up ]

Send mail to web@rfsafetysolutions.com with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2007 RF Safety Solutions LLC
Site last modified: 2/28/2007